Colorado Criminal Law – The Impact of Mental Health and Substance Abuse Issues in Criminal Cases
By H. Michael Steinberg, Colorado Criminal Defense Lawyer – 43+ Years Practicing Exclusively Colorado Criminal Law
Can a Colorado Criminal Defense Lawyer Help If Mental Health or Substance Abuse Issues Affected You at the Time of the Crime?
The short answer is yes – and often in ways that can change the direction of the case.
Many people charged with crimes in Colorado were struggling with depression, bipolar disorder, PTSD, schizophrenia, a traumatic brain injury, alcohol dependence, or drug addiction when the alleged offense happened.
Those conditions do not automatically excuse criminal conduct. But Colorado law gives an experienced defense lawyer several tools to use that evidence: to challenge the prosecution’s proof of intent, to raise competency or insanity, to steer the case into diversion or a treatment court, and to fight for a sentence built around recovery instead of incarceration.
Key Takeaways
- Colorado recognizes a legal insanity defense under C.R.S. § 16-8-101.5, entered by a formal plea of not guilty by reason of insanity.
- Even short of insanity, “mental condition” evidence can be offered to show you did not form the required mental state – but strict notice rules apply under C.R.S. § 16-8-107.
- Voluntary intoxication can negate “specific intent,” but not “knowingly” crimes; involuntary intoxication can be a complete defense (C.R.S. § 18-1-804).
- If you cannot understand the case or help your lawyer to defend the case at present, the proceedings must pause under Colorado’s competency statutes (C.R.S. § 16-8.5-101 et seq.).
- Colorado’s adult diversion statute expressly directs programs to consider people with behavioral health disorders and route them into community treatment (C.R.S. § 18-1.3-101).
Why Mental Health and Addiction Matter in a Colorado Criminal Case
Every Colorado crime has two parts: an act and a culpable mental state – “intentionally,” “knowingly,” “recklessly,” or “with criminal negligence,” as defined in C.R.S. § 18-1-501. The prosecution must prove both beyond a reasonable doubt. When a mental illness or a substance affected how a person perceived, thought, or acted, that evidence goes straight to the heart of the mental-state element – and to the question of what punishment, if any, is fair.
As a former senior career felony prosecutor in Arapahoe and Douglas Counties, I learned how prosecutors evaluate these cases. A file that reads “assault, intoxicated suspect” appears very different once the defense documents a decade of untreated PTSD, a medication change two weeks earlier, or a genuine commitment to treatment. My job is to make sure the prosecutor, the judge, and – if necessary – the jury see the whole person.
The Defense Roadmap: Five Ways a Lawyer Can Use This Evidence
1. Competency: Are You Able to Stand Trial Right Now?
Competency looks at your condition today, not at the time of the offense. Under C.R.S. § 16-8.5-101, a person is incompetent to proceed if a mental or developmental disability prevents them from having a rational and factual understanding of the proceedings or from assisting in their defense.
The defense, prosecution, or court may raise the issue under C.R.S. § 16-8.5-102, and the court can order an evaluation. If you are found incompetent, the case stops while restoration services are provided – and in some cases, charges may ultimately be dismissed.
2. Attacking the Required Mental State
Colorado allows expert evidence of a defendant’s mental condition to show that he or she lacked the culpable mental state for the charged crime. This is not the same as insanity. To use it, the defense must give notice at arraignment and the defendant must submit to a court-ordered examination, as set out in C.R.S. § 16-8-107. Strategic timing matters: once notice is given, the prosecution gets access to an evaluation, so the decision must be made carefully with your lawyer and a qualified expert.

3. Colorado’s Insanity Defense (NGRI)
Colorado defines “insanity” in C.R.S. § 16-8-101.5 to include a person so diseased or defective in mind at the time of the act as to be incapable of distinguishing right from wrong, and a person suffering from a condition that prevents forming a culpable mental state that is an essential element of the crime. The plea of not guilty by reason of insanity is governed by C.R.S. § 16-8-103.
Importantly, the statute excludes conditions caused solely by voluntary ingestion of alcohol or drugs, and moral decadence or depravity. A successful NGRI verdict usually leads to commitment to the Colorado Department of Human Services for treatment rather than prison – it is a serious decision that requires frank advice. For a deeper look, see my article Understanding the Insanity Defense.
Drugs, Alcohol, and Intoxication Under Colorado Law
Colorado’s intoxication statute, C.R.S. § 18-1-804, draws a sharp line between voluntary (self-induced) and involuntary intoxication.It also states that intoxication, by itself, is not a “mental disease or defect”under the insanity statute.
I cover this in detail in Is the Consumption of Alcohol a Defense to a Colorado Criminal Charge? and The “I Drank So Much I Blacked Out” Defense.
| Type | What It Means | Legal Effect |
|---|---|---|
| Voluntary intoxication | You knowingly took a substance you knew or should have known could intoxicate you. | Not a defense, but evidence may be offered to negate specific intent (“intentionally” / “with intent”) crimes such as burglary or first-degree murder. It does not negate “knowingly” – see People v. Snelling (Colo. App. 2022). |
| Involuntary intoxication | You were drugged without knowledge, took medication per medical advice, or did not know the substance could intoxicate. | A complete affirmative defense if you lacked capacity to conform your conduct to the law – People v. Low (Colo. 1987). |
| Addiction / substance use disorder | A diagnosed chronic condition, not a single episode. | Rarely a trial defense, but powerful for diversion, treatment court, deferred judgment, probation, and sentencing mitigation. |

The Colorado Supreme Court has explained that a defendant raising involuntary intoxication must present some credible evidence that a substance was introduced into the body, that it was not known to be an intoxicant (or was taken on medical advice), that it disturbed mental or physical capacities, and that it left the person unable to conform conduct to the law (People v. Voth, Colorado Supreme Court).
Adverse reactions to sleep aids, antidepressants, or combined prescriptions can sometimes meet this test – which is why a lawyer should obtain your complete medical and pharmacy records early.
See my recent analysis of People v. Mion (2026) and the involuntary intoxication defense and Involuntary Intoxication – The Law, Part 2.
Diversion, Treatment Courts, and Alternatives to Conviction
For many clients, the best outcome is not a trial at all. Colorado’s adult pretrial diversion statute, C.R.S. § 18-1.3-101, states that diversion programs shall consider individuals with behavioral health disorders and divert them into community treatment. A diversion agreement can include treatment, and successful completion results in dismissal. Those reforms were adopted through Senate Bill 22-010, which replaced Colorado’s earlier Mental Health Diversion pilot program. Learn more in Understanding Colorado’s Adult Pretrial Diversion System.
Other Treatment-Focused Options a Defense Lawyer Can Pursue
- Deferred judgment and sentence – plead, complete conditions such as treatment, and the case is dismissed (C.R.S. § 18-1.3-102).
- Problem-solving courts – drug courts, DUI courts, veterans treatment courts, and mental health/wellness courts operated by the Colorado Judicial Branch.
- Probation with treatment conditions – courts may order evaluation and treatment as a condition of probation (C.R.S. § 18-1.3-204).
- Drug-offense treatment alternatives – Colorado’s drug laws favor treatment for many possession offenses (C.R.S. § 18-18-403.5).
- Record sealing after dismissal or completion (C.R.S. § 24-72-705).
Mitigation: Using Your History to Win a Fair Sentence
When a conviction cannot be avoided, mental health and addiction evidence can be the difference between prison and probation. A thorough mitigation package may include a forensic psychological report, treatment records, letters from counselors and sponsors, proof of sobriety (such as monitored testing), and a concrete relapse-prevention plan. Colorado’s sentencing goals in C.R.S. § 18-1-102.5 expressly include promoting rehabilitation. I present this evidence not as an excuse, but as an explanation – and a credible path forward.
What You Should Do Right Now
- Do not talk to police about your mental health, drinking, or drug use without a lawyer. Statements meant to explain can be used to prove intent.
- Gather records – diagnoses, prescriptions, hospital visits, and counseling history.
- Start or continue treatment now; early engagement is powerful evidence.
- Do not sign releases for the prosecution until your lawyer reviews them.
- Call an experienced Colorado criminal defense lawyer before arraignment (see Is It Important to Hire a Criminal Defense Lawyer Early in the Process?), because notice deadlines for mental-condition and insanity defenses arrive early.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is being drunk or high a defense in Colorado?
Generally no, but voluntary intoxication may negate specific intent for certain crimes under C.R.S. § 18-1-804(1), and involuntary intoxication can be a full defense.
Will raising mental health hurt my case?
It can, if done carelessly. Giving notice of a mental-condition defense triggers a court-ordered examination. A lawyer should first obtain a confidential defense evaluation before deciding.
Can I get diversion if my case involves a victim?
Possibly. Eligibility depends on the district attorney’s policies and the statutory exclusions in C.R.S. § 18-1.3-101, and skilled advocacy often makes the difference.
Is “insanity” the same as having a mental illness?
No. Many people with serious mental illness do not meet Colorado’s legal definition of insanity in C.R.S. § 16-8-101.5. Other defenses and alternatives are often more useful.
Related Articles by H. Michael Steinberg
- Understanding Affirmative Defenses to Colorado Criminal Charges
- Understanding the Insanity Defense
- Is the Consumption of Alcohol a Defense to a Colorado Criminal Charge?
- People v. Mion (2026): The Involuntary Intoxication Defense
- Understanding Colorado’s Adult Pretrial Diversion System
- Involuntary Commitments, 72-Hour Holds, and Involuntary Medication
Facing Charges Where Mental Health or Addiction Played a Role?
H. Michael Steinberg has defended Coloradans for more than 43 years – including 13 years as a senior felony prosecutor. Get experienced, compassionate, and aggressive representation today.
Disclaimer: This article is for general educational purposes and is not legal advice. Colorado law changes; consult a licensed Colorado criminal defense attorney about your specific situation.
Colorado Criminal Lawyer Blog


